Clinical Negligence Investigation – Report Summary
A final report commissioned by Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust has been published (Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust) following the recall of hundreds of patients treated by Orthopaedic Surgeon Mr Mian Munawar Shah. The findings highlight a range of serious concerns regarding the care Mr Shah provided over a number of years, including surgical errors, technical incompetency, and lack of appropriate follow-up.
The Clinical Negligence team at Waldrons Solicitors has been actively assisting a number of former patients of Mr Shah to seek compensation for harm caused by negligent treatment. A formal protocol has been agreed between Waldrons and the Trust’s legal representatives for the management of these claims.
Background of the Case
Mr Shah was employed by the Trust as an Orthopaedic Surgeon from 2004. Concerns began to be raised in early 2020, which led to a widespread patient recall and internal review. Mr Shah was fully suspended by the Trust in 2021. [Express & Star]
A detailed investigation was launched, including an analysis of procedures carried out since 2010. The Trust’s report, published on 11th March 2025, found that:
- 382 patients had undergone procedures of concern.
- 24% of those patients experienced moderate to severe harm due to surgical error. [ITV News]
- The highest harm rate was linked to Latarjet procedures, where 43% of patients were harmed.
- Other high-risk surgeries included shoulder replacements, elbow joint replacements and hand and wrist procedures involving bone fusion and grafting. [Health Service Journal]
The review also criticised the Trust’s lack of appropriate safeguards, which enabled Mr Shah to move into complex upper limb surgeries without the required competency. [BBC News Midlands]
Waldrons’ Role in Supporting Patients
At Waldrons Solicitors, our Clinical Negligence specialists have been working with individuals and families affected by Mr Shah’s care. We are committed to helping clients understand the harm caused and pursue fair and compassionate compensation.
A structured process is now in place for the handling of these claims. Our team ensures that each case is treated with care, respect, and expert insight, using independent medical assessments to build strong legal arguments. [Waldrons News]
Statement from Adam Smith
Adam Smith, Clinical Negligence Solicitor at Waldrons Solicitors, who is assisting several clients affected by Mr Shah, commented:
“The findings of the report are deeply concerning, particularly the number of patients who suffered avoidable harm. Many of these individuals were left with lasting physical and emotional consequences from procedures that should never have gone ahead.
We welcome the publication of the report, but we recognise that this is only the beginning of the journey for many affected patients. We are here to support those individuals in pursuing justice and securing the compensation they deserve.”
If you are Affected
If you believe you were treated by Mr Mian Munawar Shah and are concerned about the care you received, you may be entitled to bring a claim.
Our Clinical Negligence team at Waldrons Solicitors offers a free, no-obligation consultation to discuss your experience in complete confidence.
About Adam Smith
Click here to learn more about Adam Smith: Adam is a Solicitor in our Clinical Negligence Department. He has extensive experience handling complex medical negligence claims and is currently supporting multiple clients affected by Mr Shah’s care. He is known for his compassionate, clear and dedicated approach to helping clients navigate these difficult cases.
